Another Win for Nursing Students Religious Rights

Protecting Religious Beliefs in Clinical Placements

Reprinted with permission from A Voice For Choice Advocacy

---

Across the United States, students entering healthcare and nursing programs are often told that religious exemptions are respected until the clinical placement stage. At that point, many universities claim that exemptions no longer count, citing hospital requirements and leaving students feeling powerless, confused, and under extreme pressure to comply.

But A Voice for Choice Advocacy continues to see that when students stand in faith and on firm legal ground while asserting their religious exemptions to vaccine requirements, they can continue in their programs and career dreams without compromising their beliefs. Over the next three days we are going to share three similar but different stories that show these successes. If you know of any student wanting to go into the healthcare field, whose religious beliefs are against vaccination, please refer the to AVFCA so we can help them navigate the issue sucessfully.

A Voice for Choice Advocacy is pleased to share a recent case referred to us by No College Mandates, involving a nursing student at a private evangelical Christian university in Indiana.

Sydney, a hardworking nursing student, had religious exemption forms on file with her university. As she prepared for her clinical rotations beginning January 2026, she was unexpectedly told that she must receive the MMR, Varicella, Hepatitis B and influenza vaccine and that her religious exemption would not be accepted. She was given only days to comply, putting her academic future at risk.

When Sydney asked where to submit her religious accommodation request, she was told that only medical exemptions were accepted. University officials repeatedly said that their clinical partners required vaccination and would not allow religious exemptions, and that her placement could not be guaranteed if she did not get vaccinated against influenza.

With support from AVFCA, Sydney approached the situation thoughtfully and strategically. She maintained clear professional communication, documented every exchange, and consistently affirmed her sincerely held religious beliefs. Rather than giving in to pressure, Sydney continued advocating for herself calmly, respectfully, and persistently with AVFCA’s guidance.

AVFCA assisted Sydney in preparing formal written requests, asserting her legal protections, and requiring the university to put its claims in writing. Once accountability and documentation were established, the situation shifted. The university ultimately allowed her to move forward in the placement process without forcing her to compromise her religious convictions.

This case highlights a reality AVFCA sees far too often: institutions frequently rely on urgency, uncertainty, and incomplete information to pressure students into compliance. When students are informed, supported, and persistent, those tactics lose their power.

AVFCA is the only organization that has had documented success helping students secure clinical placements on the basis of sincerely held religious exemptions. If you or someone you know is preparing to enter a healthcare program that requires clinical placements, start early. These cases often take time, and waiting until the last minute can create unnecessary stress and disruption.

Many families are approached by attorneys or organizations that claim they can help in these situations, but often lack a full understanding of the applicable law or any demonstrated track record of success in clinical placement cases. In some instances, families are asked to pay significant legal fees without meaningful results.

AVFCA has built its expertise through years of hands-on advocacy and real-world outcomes. We provide this guidance at no cost, so that every student, regardless of financial resources, has access to knowledgeable, effective support.

Thank you for helping us make victories like this possible! AVFCA is completely funded by donations made by people like you. Your donations enable us to keep standing up for individuals facing similar challenges. Over the last 10 years A Voice for Choice Advocacy, and our sister organization, A Voice for Choice, have been sustained only by grassroots donations, as well as my own significant donations. We are so thankful to everyone who has generously donated. However, AVFCA always needs your help to make our efforts sustainable. If you appreciate the work we do, AVFCA asks you to donate as generously as you can - no amount is too little or too great! If you are not already, please consider becoming a monthly donor:

www.avoiceforchoiceadvocacy.org/donate

If you don’t want to use Stripe, here are some other ways to donate:

Send Check to: A Voice for Choice Advocacy/A Voice for Choice, 530 Showers Drive #7404, Mountain View CA 94040
Send Venmo to: @avoiceforchoice (Note: you have to search under “Business” to find us)
Send PayPal to: AVFCA – info@avoiceforchoiceadvocacy.org or AVFC – info@avoiceforchoice.org
Send Zelle to: AVFCA – info@avoiceforchoiceadvocacy.org or AVFC – info@avoiceforchoice.org
Donate your used vehicle in a hassle free way, while getting a tax deductible receipt for your donation. CLICK HERE
Donate stock through Stock Donator, which processes stock donations for non profits. A Voice for Choice will receive your donation and you will not have to pay capital gains tax on your donation. CLICK HERE
Donate cryptocurrency through Every.org, which processes cryptocurrency donations for non profits. CLICK HERE

Thank you in advance for your generosity. Together we can make change happen!

Christina Hildebrand
President/Founder
A Voice for Choice Advocacy, Inc.
christina@avoiceforchoiceadvocacy.org
www.AVoiceForChoiceAdvocacy.org